20 Inch vs 16 Inch Tool Chests: Which Should You Buy?
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
Choosing between a 20 Inch vs 16 Inch tool chest depends on your space and storage style. Both units offer rolling mobility and locking security for your garage or workshop. The main difference lies in their internal organization and footprint. One provides multiple drawers for small parts, while the other uses adjustable shelves for bulkier items. You need to decide which layout fits your workflow better.
Key differences
| Aspect | IDEALHOUSE 20-Inch 5-Drawer Red Tool Chest | Reemoon 71 in Black Storage Cabinet |
|---|---|---|
| Width | 17.3 inches | 32 inches |
| Depth | 20 inches | 16 inches |
| Height | 29.5 inches | 71 inches |
| Storage Type | 5 drawers | 5 adjustable shelves |
| Material | Cold-rolled steel | Powder-coated steel |
Which one should you choose?
Choose IDEALHOUSE 20-Inch 5-Drawer Red Tool Chest if
- You need dedicated drawers to separate small tools and hardware.
- You prefer a lower profile that fits under standard workbenches.
- You want soft-lined drawers to protect delicate measuring instruments.
Choose Reemoon 71 in Black Storage Cabinet if
- You need vertical storage to maximize floor space in a small garage.
- You store larger bins, containers, or bulky power tools.
- You want interior pegboard organization on the door for hand tools.
Verdict: Choose the 20-inch model if you prioritize organized, drawer-based storage for hand tools. Pick the 16-inch cabinet if you need tall, vertical space for larger items and bins. Both offer secure, rolling storage for your workspace.
20 Inch vs 16 Inch Chests Compared
Depth and Footprint
The IDEALHOUSE 20-Inch 5-Drawer Red Tool Chest offers a depth of 28.5 inches, providing a substantial base for your tools. In contrast, the Reemoon 71 in Black Storage Cabinet is significantly shallower at 16 inches deep. This 16-inch depth allows the Reemoon unit to fit into tighter spaces or against walls where a deeper cabinet would protrude too far into the room. If you have limited floor space in a garage or workshop, the narrower footprint of the Reemoon cabinet is a practical advantage. The IDEALHOUSE unit requires more clearance but offers a larger surface area for organizing items in rows.
Width and Capacity
Width is a critical factor for storing larger tools and equipment. The Reemoon 71 in Black Storage Cabinet features a width of 32 inches, which is nearly double the 17.3-inch width of the IDEALHOUSE 20-Inch 5-Drawer Red Tool Chest. This wider design allows the Reemoon cabinet to accommodate bulkier items, such as large toolboxes, paint cans, or storage bins, side by side. The IDEALHOUSE unit, while narrower, is designed with multiple drawers to organize smaller hand tools efficiently. For users who need to store wide items or prefer open shelving over drawer organization, the Reemoon cabinet provides superior width capacity.
Drawers and Shelves
Internal organization differs significantly between these two units. The IDEALHOUSE model comes with five drawers, allowing you to separate wrenches, sockets, screwdrivers, and hardware into distinct compartments. This is ideal for keeping small parts visible and accessible. The Reemoon cabinet uses five adjustable shelves instead of drawers. Each shelf supports up to 170 lb, making it suitable for heavy items like power tools or containers. The Reemoon also includes a door pegboard for hanging frequently used hand tools. If you prefer compartmentalized storage, the IDEALHOUSE drawers are better. For heavy, bulky items, the Reemoon shelves are superior.
Height and Vertical Space
Vertical space utilization is another key difference. The Reemoon 71 in Black Storage Cabinet stands 71 inches tall, making it a tall storage solution that uses vertical space effectively. This height allows for storing tall items and maximizing capacity in a small floor area. The IDEALHOUSE 20-Inch 5-Drawer Red Tool Chest is much shorter at 29.5 inches high. This lower profile makes it easier to access tools without a step stool and fits under most standard workbenches. If you have high ceilings and want to store more items vertically, the Reemoon cabinet is the better choice. For easy access and low profile, the IDEALHOUSE unit is preferred.
Material and Build
Both units are constructed from steel, but the finishes and construction methods differ. The IDEALHOUSE tool chest is made from heavy-duty cold-rolled steel with a rust-resistant finish, designed to resist bending and warping under daily use. It also features soft, non-slip liners in each drawer to cushion tools. The Reemoon cabinet uses a powder-coated steel body, which provides a durable finish for everyday garage or warehouse storage. While both are steel, the IDEALHOUSE unit emphasizes drawer-specific protection with liners, whereas the Reemoon focuses on a general durable coating for its shelves and doors. The choice depends on whether you prioritize drawer protection or general cabinet durability.
Which tool chest fits your needs
Mechanics needing deep drawer storage
The IDEALHOUSE unit features five drawers with soft liners to cushion tools and prevent sliding. Its 28.5-inch depth and 17.3-inch width offer a stable base for heavy wrenches and sockets. The detachable top box adds portable storage, while the built-in lock secures drawers during movement or when parked in a shared shop.
Users storing large bins and supplies
The Reemoon cabinet provides 71 inches of vertical height and 32 inches of width, maximizing floor space efficiency. Its five adjustable shelves support up to 170 pounds each, handling heavy toolboxes and bulk supplies. The interior door pegboard keeps hand tools visible, while the powder-coated steel body resists daily wear in utility areas.
Homeowners wanting organized small parts
Multiple drawer sizes allow you to separate hardware, drill bits, and measuring tools for fast access. The non-slip liners keep items in place, reducing noise and protecting delicate accessories. This 57.3-pound cabinet moves smoothly on four casters, including two lockable wheels, making it easy to reposition in a garage or basement workshop.
Quick picks
| # | Product | Best for | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | IDEALHOUSE 20-Inch 5-Drawer Red Tool Chest | detachable storage and tool protection | Check price of IDEALHOUSE 20-Inch 5-Drawer Red Tool Chest on Amazon |
| 2 | Reemoon 71 in Black Storage Cabinet | vertical storage and hand tool organization | Check price of Reemoon 71 in Black Storage Cabinet on Amazon |
The products compared
IDEALHOUSE 20-Inch 5-Drawer Red Tool Chest
Best for: detachable storage and tool protection
- Depth
- 20 Inch (what this guide is about)
- Drawers
- 5
- Width
- 17.3
- Material
- heavy-duty cold-rolled steel
- Locking System
- built-in locking system
- Casters
- 4 all-purpose casters, 2 lockable
View on Amazon: IDEALHOUSE 20-Inch 5-Drawer Red Tool Chest Affiliate link
This 20-inch tool chest offers 5 drawers in a 2-in-1 detachable design. It measures 28.5 inches deep and 29.5 inches high. The heavy-duty cold-rolled steel construction resists bending. Four all-purpose casters, including two lockable wheels, provide mobility. Soft-lined drawers protect tools. It suits DIYers needing portable storage for garage or workshop use.
Pros
- 2-in-1 detachable top organizer for portable use
- Heavy-duty cold-rolled steel resists warping
- Soft-lined drawers cushion tools and reduce noise
- Built-in locking system secures drawers and doors
- Four casters with two lockable wheels for stability
Cons
- 57.3 pounds weight makes it heavy to move
- 17.3 inches width is narrower than standard 20-inch chests
- No remote or app control for smart features
Good fit if
- You need a detachable top box for job site portability
- You store small parts and hand tools in separate drawers
- You want soft liners to protect delicate measuring tools
Skip if
- You require a wider 20-inch chest for large power tools
- You need more than five drawers for extensive collections
- You prefer a lighter unit for frequent relocation
Verdict: IDEALHOUSE 20 Inch 5 Drawer Tool Chest fits users who value portable storage and tool protection in a compact steel frame. Its detachable design and soft liners make it ideal for mechanics and DIYers working in tight garage spaces.
Reemoon 71 in Black Storage Cabinet
Best for: vertical storage and hand tool organization
- Depth
- 16 Inch (what this guide is about)
- Width
- 32 inches
- Material
- Powder-coated steel
- Locking System
- Door lock with 2 keys
- Casters
- 4 removable locking rubber casters
- Pegboard
- Door pegboard
View on Amazon: Reemoon 71 in Black Storage Cabinet Affiliate link
This 16-inch deep cabinet measures 32 inches wide and 71 inches tall, using vertical space for tools and supplies. It features five adjustable shelves, each supporting up to 170 pounds. A door pegboard keeps hand tools visible. The powder-coated steel body includes four removable locking casters and a door lock with two keys for secure storage.
Pros
- 5 adjustable shelves supporting 170 lb each
- Door pegboard for hand tool organization
- 4 removable locking rubber casters
- Powder-coated steel construction
Cons
- 16-inch depth limits large item storage
- Requires assembly
- No internal drawers for small parts
Good fit if
- You need vertical storage in a narrow space
- You want to organize hand tools on a pegboard
- You require mobile storage with locking casters
Skip if
- You need deep storage for bulky equipment
- You want built-in drawers for small parts
- You prefer a pre-assembled unit
Verdict: Reemoon 16 Inch Tool Cabinet offers high capacity with adjustable shelves and mobility. It fits users who prioritize vertical organization and secure, movable storage over deep compartments.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | IDEALHOUSE 20-Inch 5-Drawer Red Tool Chest | Reemoon 71 in Black Storage Cabinet |
|---|---|---|
| Drawers | 5 | not stated |
| Width | 17.3 | 32 inches |
| Material | heavy-duty cold-rolled steel | Powder-coated steel |
| Locking System | built-in locking system | Door lock with 2 keys |
| Casters | 4 all-purpose casters, 2 lockable | 4 removable locking rubber casters |
| Pegboard | not stated | Door pegboard |
| Application | Garage, Workshop | Garage |
| Color | Red | Black |
| Depth | 20 Inch | 16 Inch |
| Dimensions | 28.5 × 17.3 × 29.5 inches | 16 × 32 × 71 inches |
| Weight | 57.3 pounds | 79 pounds |
| Size | 20 inch 5 Drawers | 16"D x 32"W x 71"H |
| Model | ZRZig966m | SK-ZGMD-B |
Frequently asked questions
Is a 20 inch tool chest too deep for my garage?
A 20 inch chest requires more floor depth than a 16 inch model. The IDEALHOUSE unit measures 28.5 inches in length. Ensure you have at least that much clearance in front of the unit. This depth allows for larger tools but reduces walkway space.
Which chest is better for small workshops?
The 16 inch Reemoon cabinet is better for tight spaces. It measures 16 inches in depth, saving significant floor area. Its 71 inch height maximizes vertical storage. This footprint fits easily into narrow garage corners where a wider chest would not.
Does the 20 inch chest have enough drawers?
The top-rated 20 inch IDEALHOUSE model includes five drawers. This configuration provides distinct compartments for different tool sets. The drawers feature soft liners to protect tools. This setup keeps wrenches and sockets organized without cluttering your workbench.
Can I move these chests easily?
Both units are designed for mobility. The IDEALHOUSE chest weighs 57.3 pounds and includes wheels. The Reemoon cabinet weighs 79 pounds and also features casters. You can roll them across garage floors. The lighter 20 inch chest is easier to reposition frequently.
Is the 16 inch cabinet good for hand tools?
Yes, the Reemoon cabinet excels at hand tool organization. It uses adjustable shelves rather than deep drawers. This design suits hammers, pliers, and screwdrivers. The 32 inch width offers ample surface area for sorting smaller items vertically.
Which chest offers more secure storage?
Both models provide locking security for your tools. The IDEALHOUSE chest has a steel frame and detachable design for added protection. The Reemoon cabinet offers a sturdy black steel construction. Both units keep your equipment safe from unauthorized access in your garage.